Can you Substitute Mayo for Sour Cream?

You may be in the middle of preparing your salad, but then you discover that you do not have enough sour cream to dress it, or you have run out of sour cream.

You do not need to worry because you can alternatively use mayo in its place.

You can multi-purposely use sour cream in the kitchen alongside many dishes.

You can use it as toppings, or it can be part of the recipe.

In this article, I will guide you on how you can substitute mayo for sour cream.

DISCLOSURE: CrumbKitchen.com is reader supported so if you buy any products featured on this site I may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read my full disclosure here.

Mayo as a Substitute for Sour Cream

Cooking is a skill that is enjoyable and experimental if you give your heart to it.

Being a middle-aged woman, I enjoy trying out different recipes, some of which produce delicious meals and some, well, they backfire.

That does not stop me from trying over and over again until I produce the meal I had in mind.

I enjoying baking as well, and for that case, I can never fail to have mayo or sour cream in my kitchen.

The treason is, these two are perfect substitutes for one another.

If I am in the middle of preparing salads, then I realize that I do not have enough of one of the two.

I do not panic because I know perfectly well that I can use sour cream if I run out of mayo and vice versa.

Additionally, when you combine mayonnaise with other ingredients, you will be able to produce your sour cream.

To prepare this substitute, you will require the following:

  • One third amount of plain yoghurt
  • One third amount of mayonnaise
  • One-third amount of heavy cream

It is important to measure the ingredients equally so that one ingredient does not overpower the other.

Step 1: Mixing

Take the three ingredients and mix them well using a blender.

If you do not have a blender, you put them in a bowl and mix them well using a whisk.

Step 2: Mix Till Consistent

For a smooth and creamy texture like the sour cream, turn the processor on medium speed.

The results should be consistent; creamy and light, similar to sour cream.

Step 3: Storing

Store the mixture in a container with a lid to prevent any contamination.

Once the results are satisfactory, store them in a cool and dry place until you need to use them.

Take equal amounts of the sour cream and use it the same you would have with mayonnaise.

Sour cream serves as fat when baking, and its function is to add moistness and richness to the food you are baking.

Remember, most sour cream substitutes contain dairy. You will have to be careful in case you are lactose intolerant.

However, there are dairy-free sour creams and yoghurts that you can use if you are interested in that kind of option.

Mayo As A Substitute For Sour Cream

So, can you substitute Mayo for Sour Cream?

Yes, if you are to compare all the substitutes you can use, mayonnaise tops them all.

It is frustrating when you are looking for an ingredient that you were sure you had either in the fridge or the pantry.

That is when you will need a good substitute.

Yes, you can substitute mayonnaise for sour cream.

You will only require a few ingredients such as heavy cream, mayo and plain yoghurt.

It is due to the following reasons:

  • It is creamy
  • It has a smooth texture
  • Its flavour is tangent, just like sour cream.